Butch Cassidy's Cafe Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to Butch Cassidy's Cafe, a hidden gem located in Mobile, Alabama. With its cozy atmosphere and attentive staff, this cafe offers a menu that pays homage to classic Southern flavors with a modern twist. At the heart of the menu are mouthwatering burgers like the Butch Cassidy Burger and the Prairie Burger, both acclaimed for their generous portions and delightful flavors.
Don’t miss out on the fried green tomatoes and pollo nachos, highly praised by patrons for their crispy textures and savory toppings. The selection of super salads like the Desperado Chicken Taco Salad adds a refreshing note, perfect for lighter fare. Complement your meal with handcrafted beverages, where the iced tea and coffee offer unlimited refills, enhancing your dining experience.
Butch Cassidy's promises great food at affordable prices, making each visit worthwhile. Join the locals who rave about this place—and discover why it’s the go-to spot for comfort food in Mobile!
Appetizers
Hombre Nachos
nacho chips with cheese, salsa, & jalapenos.... sour cream .50 extra
Rio Grande Nachos
beer, chili, salsa, lettuce, tomatoes, salsa, & jalapenos...sour cream .50 extra
Pollo Nachos
chunks of chicken, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, salsa, & jalapenos...sour cream .50 extra
Tombstone
chips & salsa
Baggs Wyoming Buffalo Wings
great as an appetizer or a meal... nice and spicy
Cassidy Fries
Butch's Chilli Cheese Fries
Outlaw Rings
Wild Bunch Shrooms
fried mushrooms with dip...
South Pass
cheese sticks...
San Jaun Peppers
jalapeno stuffed with crabmeat & served with special sauce...
Fried Green Tomatoes
Fried Pickles
pikel fried sample but really tasty why not
Desperado Taco Salad
beef, chili, sour cream, olives, lettuce, peppers, & salsa
Desperado Chicken Taco Salad
Roosters Salad
char broil chicken breast on a bed of salad fixins'
Chief Salad
lot's of ham, turkey, & cheese! your choice of dressing
Etta's House Salad
an healthy addition to any meal...
Fried Roasters Salad
fried chicken strips on a bed of salad fixings...
South Paw Shrimp Salad
the soecial and refreshin taste of the gulf shrimp on top of bed lettuce
Super Salads
B.c Specialities
Telluride Rooster Finger
the best chicken finger ever ...served with honey mustard fries or slaw onion ring for a 1.25
Holl In The Wall Chili
eat as a meal ar appetizer it 'll warm ya up
Texas Tecos Build Yer Own
guaranteed to spice yer life up
Soon To Be Our Famous Butch Burger
bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, mustard, mayonnaise, & pickles
Jesse James Sourdough Burger
the sourdough, grilled onions, & mustard make it one of our favorites!
Wild West Burger
this one's got lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, mustard, & mayonnaise
Babe Burger
same as our wild west burger but for a smaller appetite...
Calamity Jane Patty Melt
beef patty on grilled onion or chadder
Hamburgers
Sandwiches
Brown's Park Steak Sandwich
6 oz. usda rib eye cooked to order with sourdough, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, & pickles
Train-robber Philly Steak
it will steal your taste buds, spicy roast beef/ grilled onions/peppers & swiss cheese, add au jus .50 cents
Char Grilled Robber's Roost
7 oz. of skinless chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, pickles, & mayonnaise
Pinkerton Club
fresh turkey, ham, bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato, & mayonnaise
Woodcock Turkey On Sourdough
delicious turkey topped with lettuce, tomato, & pickles...served hot off the
E. H. Hiram Ham & Cheese
select ham severed on philly bread with lettuce, tomato, pickles, & mayonnaise...served hot or cold
Sundance Reuben
one of our best sellers! prepared and severed hot on rye bread
Pay Master B.l.t.
the old stage coach standby severed on white or wheat bread...
Campfire Grilled Cheese
for cheese lovers only! four slice of american cheese on sourdough bread
The Jail Bird
select turkey severed on train-robbers bread with lettuce, tomato, pickles, & mayonnaise
Leroy Poboy
shrimp, oysters. fish or chicken topped with lettuce, tomato, onions, & pickles
Pam\s Stage Coach Meat Loaf
served in hot sourdough with lettuce , pikel and mayo
Add Chili
Slaw
Au Jus
Bacon
Jalapenos
Sour Cream
Garlic Bread
Add Cheese Of Your Choice
Add Side Salad
Sauteed Onion
Sauteed Shrooms
Sauteed Green Pepper
Buck
Broccoli
Extra Dressing
Mercantile Item
Dessert
Plantation Key Lime Pie
Nanner Pudding
Soft Drinks
coke, sprite, diet coke, or minute maid lemonade
Iced Tea & Coffee
free refills on tea & coffee
Domestic Beer
bud, bud light, miller, miller lite, coors light, michelob, michelob light, rolling rock, rolling rock light
Imported Beer
heineken, corona, fosters, bass, dos esquis, red strip, haake beck (nonalcoholic)
Wine By The Glass
sutterhome chardonnay, white zinfandel, cabernet sauvignon, merlot